patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Should The Herald-Tribune Stop Political Endorsements?

Herald-Tribune's parent company Halifax Media announced it will cease candidate and political endorsements at all of its newspapers.

 

How much do you rely on the newspaper when you head into the polls?

Those looking for last-minute advice on whom they should vote for will have to go elsewhere as The Herald-Tribune's parent company Halifax Media announced in one of the Herald-Tribune's sister papers, The Ledger. Charter amendments will continue to be up for endorsement.

The Lakeland Ledger shared with its readers that Halifax in an Aug. 16 memo called for all of its papers to stop political endorsements and candidate endorsements in its editorials. Halifax CEO Michael Redding said that endorsements are perceived as unfair, The Ledger reported:

"Endorsing and recommending candidates has the potential to create the idea we are not able to fairly cover political races," Redding said. "Right or wrong, it is the perception."

And when endorsements are created, it can both hurt and help a newspaper, The Tampa Tribune reported:

"Sometimes it annoys more readers than it enlightens," said University of South Florida political scientist Susan MacManus. "When so much information is available on candidates from other sources, you're not educating voters as much.

"News is a business, and the payback for endorsements has been minimized while the blowback is intensifying."

It's not exactly a new debate, but it's a position that larger, well established newspapers are reconsidering. Chicago Sun-Times in January and the Atlanta Journal Constitution in 2009 have both halted endorsements.

Then there are newspapers that reaffirm the importance of endorsements. Just days after the Sun-Times said it would no longer provide endorsements or recommendations, the Chicago Tribune touted the service:

"In our editorials, we explain what we think should be done about government pension costs, educational shortcomings, political dysfunction and more. We offer our opinions on issues from the mundane to the cosmic.

Not least important, we endorse candidates, from the top of the ballot to the bottom. To arrive at our choices, we send out questionnaires, scrutinize voting records and public statements, and interview hundreds of candidates. We make our evaluation of which ones will best serve the interests of the public. And then we tell our readers."

The biggest help for voters, experts told The Tampa Tribune is for those offices where the only coverage is the endorsement itself — mainly judges and court posts.

Do political endorsements and recommendations from newspapers help you decide who and what to vote for? Will you miss the Herald-Tribune's endorsements? Tell us in the comments.

About this column: Find all your election profiles, news and stories right here. Related Topics: Halifax Media, Herald-Tribune Candidate Endorsements, Herald-Tribune Endorsements, Herald-Tribune Political Endorsements, Newspaper Endorsements, and elections 2012

John Garvey

4:08 pm on Monday, September 17, 2012

I read the Sarasota Herald Tribune for the local news and the convenience of reading a paper at a coffee shop or wherever I want to. Their editorials? LOL They're a joke, obviously politically biased and only a fool would pay them the slightest of attention. Irritating? They can be if read but when something is that predictable, WHY READ IT?

Reply

Paige Farr

7:17 am on Thursday, September 20, 2012

I like to read the Herald Tribune, and I am really happy to hear they will no longer endorse candidates. We already know they have a liberal bias, and I feel a newspaper has no business promoting one candidate over another. We all need to do our own homework and decide who we support. Endorsing candidates smacks of union propaganda telling their members for whom to vote.

Reply

Mme. d'Estape

8:27 pm on Sunday, September 23, 2012

The decision to drop endorsements, right or wrong, needs to be explained carefully and in depth by a paper that has long seen it as not simply a right, but a responsibility to take a stand on the most important matter of governance - who rules us. If the actual reason is that, as noted above. it doesn't "pay," because news is a business:

"News is a business, and the payback for endorsements has been minimized while the blowback is intensifying."

Then in all honesty stop editorializing altogether. You (Herald Trib) are merely another business - a car dealer, a supermarket, a hooker on Main St. Newspapers began as shoppers and apparently if Halifax has anything to do with it, they will return to that status. Let them do so - honorably, by dropping the pretense that they are "objective," "disinterested," and for the people, as opposed to what they really are: ad vehicles for the Chamber of Commerce crowd. And don't forget who rules the Chamber in DC: Grover Norquist.

Reply

George Rahal

11:04 am on Monday, October 8, 2012

Herald Tribune, as an informed community leader, can and should provide a service to the community by providing endorsements and summaries of the reasons why.

Reply

Leave a comment