Mitt Romney recently said he would “get rid of” Planned Parenthood to help balance the budget.
Planned Parenthood is a vital health care provider for millions of American women in need of affordable health care and life-saving services such as cancer screenings, birth control, and other preventative care. Romney’s plan to ‘get rid of’ Planned Parenthood would put the health care of millions of American women at risk. And it would have almost zero effect on balancing the budget.
With this pledge to get rid of Planned Parenthood, Mitt Romney has once again shown there are no limits to what he will say to pander to the extreme right wing of the Republican Party.
Even though he supported the Blunt Amendment (allowing any employer to refuse any medical coverage for moral reasons) and Mississippi’s personhood bill, and he flip flopped on abortion rights, Mitt Romney still can’t close the deal with his party’s base. So he has now decided to try an even more extreme and desperate strategy -- promising to get rid of a 95-year old organization that one in five American women has depended on for health care services.
Mitt Romney just doesn’t get it. America’s women aren’t interested in being pawns in his quest to pander his way to power. His attack on Planned Parenthood is bad for women, bad for America, and it’s just going to backfire on him.
bart weckman
12:16 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
good try...look at who the writer of the article is...this is pure politics...tells us how the democrat extremists try to tilt and distort facts...
Joyce Abate-Bonaiuto
12:58 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
Planned Parenthood performs abortions for women. When researched, as well as Planned Parenthood personnel videoed by News programs across the nation, it was found that Planned Parenthood's main objective is to provide abortions, with many abortions being done well after they should be. When Planned Parenthood agencies across the nation were called to ask about what health services they provide for women (namely mammograms), their personnel directly responded that they do not offer women mammogram screenings and other necessary health screenings for women. Mitt Romney supports the fact that this country's financial direction and economy has been declining because this current Federal Administration has over spent our tax dollars on programs of entitlement and is mis-managing our tax dollars - i.e.: Planned Parenthood is one example. The ultimate issue and question here is this: do we want our tax dollars to continue to be spent supporting the killing of fetuses? Many of us do not - and a large part of "us" are women across our nation.
Deborah G Flynn
4:22 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
Amen if you want to kill a bay then pay for it yourself or have your boyfriend if you remeber who it was pay
Dr Geoff Clarke
4:13 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
And as a Practicning physcian I am appalled by the deceitful pandering by the liberals to make it seem like they are actually a help. If in my opinion, the liberals are fine with abortions and Planned Parenthood, then put their money where their mouth is and donate to them. Their feigned outrage and inciting poor women is a total disgrace. They claim that they do nOT use public funds for abortions? Really? They use the public funds to keep the doors open and have the venue to perform abortions at will while hiding the fact they do little else. Goeff
John Scolaro
1:05 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
But then again Obama never panders and never promises his base or any other unintelligent person anything they want to hear over and over again no matter the facts, truth, reality or otherwise. Never does the entire democratic party do the same. And certainly the main-stream media and any other left-leaning propagandist never does the same, other than every day and all the time.
Henry Bright
1:12 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
John and Bart, typical ad hominem attacks - when you can't argue the facts, attack the messenger. And on this, you really can't argue the facts.
Brian Christopher
3:35 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
So the "fact" is that there is a war on women because Mitt doesn't want the government sending cash to groups that provide abortions? Interesting...
Deborah G Flynn
4:24 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
There is no war on women. Period That is just the garbage the left keeps telling these victim mentlality women who want someone else to take care of them. I'm a very independant woman and if you want to be a victim the left will show you a millions and one ways how to be one.
Cathy
3:50 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
I cannot find anything in the Constitution that gives the Federal gov't the responsibility or right to provide healthcare directly or indirectly. Can we please go back to the rule book?
I am in favor of concerned citizens offering assistance to those who can not afford necessary medical services. St. Jude is a great example. Forcing people to have or provide healthcare to their neighbors less then charitable. Expecting other to be responsible for you is selfish.
Deborah G Flynn
4:18 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
The constitution calls for LIMITED Goevernment and life liberty and the persuit of happiness.......not Obama's mantra of tax , spend and the persuit of everything in my neighbos wallet and free cell phone and health care. Charity is neither a form or function of government which has proven to be wasteful. The private charities are better skilled and more suitable to help. The baby killing Planned PArenthood is just a taxpayer funded arm of the Democratic Party. they can spin the nu,bers[ not to me] but they need to be a totally private funded group. If you like killing babies donate by all means but don't expect me to
Shakira Refos
5:05 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
Which rule book are you referring to?
Dr Geoff Clarke
4:21 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
Well said. I keep saying I'm a physician not to be heard but to say in my field of expertise which is different , not better,than the average woman who is desparate trouble. Do you know almost EVERY hopspital has an outreach program for free mammography? Do you know most county health services give vouchers for birth control? Do you know the drug companies themseleves have programs to get free birth control and many other products with just a simple phone call? Do you realize that many of provide FREE care for people we know are without insurance? I have a policy in my practice that we promise the community we will see a considerable number of poor people. I hand out free medicine all the time in the sample form the drug companies give us. All this is through my church. Many doctors, dentists and lawyers do free work as a part of our community outreach program. Charity is available everywhere. If you want an abortion go to an abortion clinic like PP but don't try and deceive people iwith the lie this is anything but. that, If you want help free healthcare it is obtainable.
drd
3:54 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
There is truth and there are lies. The truth is that Planned Parenthood spends about 3% of it's money on abortion services. The other 97% is spent on cancer screenings, preventative health and other servies for women who otherwise couldn't afford them. By providing these services to low income women, Planned Parenthood saves the federal government a lot of money. It also prevents abortions. And isn't that the goal after all?
Deborah G Flynn
4:21 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
This is so far from factual it is laughable. Fact here is how they dirive their 3% claim. If 100 ladies walk in and they hand out 97 booklets and a few referrals in a day then they claim 95% of their business is services. It is fact that they perform more abortions mostly as a form of advanced birth control than any other entity. You can get free screenings at almost every level including hospitals thay have screening days. You can get free brith coontrol. The fact is this is a front for being an abortion clinic. You can't paint lipstick on that pig
Deborah G Flynn
5:40 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
#1 They spend ZERO on cancer screenings they only hand out a booklet with referral clinics listed ,
#2 They have out of every 100 visitors in a day 97 booklets are handed out they do three abortions in a day.......
ergo they claim only 3% if their business is abortions. Logic and statistics 101, did you attend college?
they skew the actual tasks. They do NOT provide mammograms or anything else. They let teenagers and their pimps leading them in to have abortions .
bart weckman
9:55 am on Friday, March 23, 2012
i question your statistics...please provide the source of these numbers...it seems that the actual breakdown of pp expenditures is the exact OPPOSITE of your claim, in other words, 97 % of pp monies go to abortions and 3 % goes to other services!!!
Dr Geoff Clarke
4:38 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
They provide NOTHING of any substance but abortions as a means of government funded disposal of unwanted babies.Lazy birth control I call it and zero personal responsibility which is what the government fosters. Call it what it is. It does NOTHING for the government other than keep the numbers of extra babies off the welfare roles. Personally the money would be better spent on helping these women get educated and build some self esteem.Make the able bodied men and women on govcernment assistance provide urine for drug screening. There is a direct correlation in medicine that drugs users in general do not have the responsibility to adhere to ANY birth control regimine. They already [majority] get Medicare so true health services are provided. The women in the gap [ working poor] definitly need compassionate help as to where and how to obtain care.
Dr Geoff Clarke
7:45 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
PREVENTS ABORTION? No offense but their main GOAL IS abortions. Goeff
Deborah G Flynn
4:26 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
BTW I had a post pulled of course because I happened to say something about Obama and his tactics those weenies, lefty folks didn't want to hear. That's the left for you if they disagree they want you removed and silenced only they have a right to their opinions, the right simply tries to educate them. They don't want to be or are so indoctrinated they can only follow like lemmings.
Shakira Refos
5:03 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
Why is everybody so angry?
Deborah G Flynn
5:28 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
Because OBAMA has divided us like noi one has ever before in the history fo the USA
Shakira Refos
5:04 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
If you dont like abortions don't have one. I didnt agree with the Iraq war but Im paying for it just the same.
Deborah G Flynn
5:29 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
That is a nice thought but OAMA keeps cramming things down our throats.
Deborah G Flynn
5:30 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
There is quite a bit of difference in a war and people getting freebies that other people are forced to pay for.
Shakira Refos
5:44 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
Oh ok. I thought your commentary was about the govt paying for something that you dont agree with.
Deborah G Flynn
5:48 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
I don't agree with a lot of things the government spends tax dollars on like all those wasteful pork projects that are ridiculous. I think we need a real conservative comptroller to go through the budget line by line and throw out every single unecessary expenditure that does not benefit the majority. We don't need a trolly car ride in the NAPA Valley for a brother of Nancy Pelosi to the tune of 35 million dollars ya think?
Shakira Refos
7:08 pm on Wednesday, March 21, 2012
You sound like Rush Limbaugh.
Henry Bright
10:06 am on Friday, March 23, 2012
bart, you say that 97 % of pp monies go to abortions and 3 % goes to other services!!!
I question your statistics...please provide the source of these numbers
bart weckman
11:38 am on Friday, March 23, 2012
i'm awaiting drd's response to my question above [and not a regurgitation of my comments]
Henry Bright
2:31 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
bart, I don't know where drd's statistics come from but the following Washington Post articles do show that abortions are 3% of PP services.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/ezra-klein/post/what-planned-parenthood-actually-does/2011/04/06/AFhBPa2C_blog.html
The methodological note:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/ezra-klein/post/about-the-planned-parenthood-chart/2011/08/25/gIQAvTlhnQ_blog.html
Now you can tell us where your statistics came from!
bart weckman
3:05 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
here you go:
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2011/apr/08/jon-kyl/jon-kyl-says-abortion-services-are-well-over-90-pe/
btw, your stats are from pp!!!!!! sorta' like having the pba investigate police brutality.
Dr Geoff Clarke
3:29 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
OK First of all you are reading an aritcle by a propnant of abortions. Second as a 32 year practicing physician here is exactly how they skew the numbers to get that 3% . 3 women come in 3 get abortions the other 97% is in the form of booklets and refeerral lists they hand out. hand out 97 booklets on how to do a self breast exam or a list of participating free clinics. They provide no services rather "info" on where they can get them free . Ergo 3 abortions and they stand around handing out booklets. The reality is their ACTUAL services are 97% abortions and 3% in any meaningful services like a practical nurse in a few centers that give a depo provera shot. Go find out for yourself. They have to claim those numbers to get Federal funding,. It is the biggest lie and scam ever purpetrated on the tax paying public in the name of "Women's Health"
bart weckman
3:33 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
they also love 2 use the term "reproductive rights"...
Dr Geoff Clarke
4:22 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
IS that a constitutional "right"?
bart weckman
4:30 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
the leftist extremists have an ever-growing list of things that they like to term as 'rights',all of which they want the nanny state to provide...let's start with housing [subsidized and sub-prime], socialized medicine, food stamps, lets get more buses and give bus-passes with their obama-bucks checks, etc,etc...
bart weckman
4:58 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
i just thought of something!!!! This is when the lightbulb lights up....i bet pp gets PAID and makes a lot of money by SELLING embryonic stem cells!!!!!!They are probably the NUMBER ONE SUPPLIER of stem cells in the world!!!!! calling Breitbart...
Dr Geoff Clarke
5:37 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
Bart, you have a quick mind and absolutely correct. They have the women who sign for an abortion give up their rights to the umbilicus and any other "Medical waste" > They just "wasted a life and they will now get more fundiung for even more "Non" government funding for abortions. We as physicians know all this having seen the botched messes and "receipts" the woman have shown us thinking it would have some explanation for their high fever, bleeding and ruptures. These poor ladies are afraid to go to the Hospital so they come through our church to my practice. Most times they need to be sent on to the Hospital for repairative surgury that is ABSOLUTELY on the taxpayer dime. Goeff
Henry Bright
6:24 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
bart, thank you for supplying the source of your statistic. According to the reference you cited, it was a statement by Jon Kyl. The article you referenced,
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2011/apr/08/jon-kyl/jon-kyl-says-abortion-services-are-well-over-90-pe/
says that Truth-O-Meter rated Kyl's statement FALSE and Kyl himself was quoted in that article as saying his statement "was not intended to be factually accurate".
While I understand your point about the figures being supplied by Planned Parenthood itself, they, after all, are the only ones that have the source information. I am quite sure that if their figures were false, their legion of enemies would already have documented that. A statement by Jon Kyl that "is not intended to be factually accurate" hardly qualifies!
bart weckman
6:37 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
i have no problem in accepting the statements of {US Senator} Jon Kyl over those self-serving comments of pp..funny how pp's allegations were never subjected to the truth-o-meter...
Dr Geoff Clarke
8:00 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
Bart, there is no truth when the fox is guarding the henhouse. No pun intended. The fact is they are far left liberal organization, funded by Progressives and the only good work they do is when the shut the lights off at night. There is nothing good or "Planned"other then lying to the taxpayer. If you ever saw an abortion and an actual live person being killed you would never again be liberal about the destruction of human life. We were called into the ER one time when a woman tried to commit suide After she saw her child screaming in pain and being basically pithed like we did frogs in Medical school. Earlier abortions are just a lot of mass and blood. After all my years as a doctor and having a wonderful wife and three girls I can tell you that image has never left my mind.It is also very dishearteng to see poor women get taken advantage of. They do get talked into it and only the very coldest of women has no mental repercussions . Goeff
Vizsla
8:03 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
Should men really have so much say in women's reproductive rights. Doesn't access to birth control lower the need for welfare?
Dr Geoff Clarke
8:39 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
This isn't a question of men having a say or not. and uite frankly the term "reproductive rights" is a made up catch phrase by the liberals. Everyone has the "right" to do with as they wish with thier minds and bodies. Just don't expect someone else to pay for your choices. That being said The point is RATIONAL people, skip the sex designation, know that Mr Romney has no desire to harm women and the sensationalistic headlines only further inflames people to have a discussion calling for common sense be ridiculed. Goeff
Dr Geoff Clarke
8:05 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
this isn't about Birth control in reality, there is no issue at all as far as most people are concerned with providing Birth control the fact is welfare folks have hard time with personal responsibility in the first place so unless they have a form of birth control that is semi permanent they don't follow through. The pill doesn't work because that requires that the put an effort forth daily. You don't understand generational welfare. It is a sickness almost in and of itself. They use abortion as a means of Brth control. That isn't a slur it is a medical opinion based on first hand experience. Goeff
Vizsla
8:23 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
Who are the they?
Vizsla
8:31 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
Here is the "generational welfare" I saw first hand at Whole Foods. Well dressed woman with a cell phone and jewelry buying a frozen goose for 90.00 dollars and presenting a WiC card. I Know this is off topic, but there are much greater faults with our government subsidies than Planned Parenthood..
Dr Geoff Clarke
8:43 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
It is all part and parcel of the liberalization of the country and the government becoming the nanny to dependant people at the expense of the people who produce.PP is just a symptom of the deception as a whole.
bart weckman
8:44 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
generational welfare is something that is not believable until you have vividly encountered it...i knew a girl who met a guy who suggested they get married [ok], have a kid [ok] and then get on welfare!!!a well thought-out life plan. wisely, she ended the relationship...while i agree that there are vastly greater fiscal problems with our current govt than pp, it's important to understand the answer a very devout catholic friend gave to me when i asked him why catholics make such a big deal about abortion, he said simply that catholics consider abortion to be murder...i never forgot that...
Henry Bright
8:55 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
So, bart, you have no trouble accepting Jon Kyl's statement even though he himself said it was not meant to be factual. And I thought we were having a rational exchange!!
Bye bye. I'm outta here.
Dr Geoff Clarke
8:56 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
Bart, I am not a Catholic but I believe taking a life is murder. We swear an oath as doctors to "First do no Harm" the doctors who perform abortions have violated their first oath. They are no good doctors in my opinion. When we have to make a sincere medical decision to abort a fetus it is with great sadness and a desire to fix all that is wrong. I persoanlly will never and have never performed one. I would beg for the child first. I look at my beautiful girls and my loving wife and think how could anyone kill something as preious as that/ But we digress this isn't an abortion debate it is about the author claiming Mitt Romney wants women to pay more. Does anyone honestly believe that? And if they do Who are they and how did they become so morally bereft? I guess we have to view the author's picture and decide how she became such a hater.
bart weckman
9:28 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
Yes, Dr Goeff, we do digress...but, that is their intent---to lead us astray like a bunch of adhd-adults...how easily and how foolishly we are distracted by lrft-wing extremists' "red flags"...it is done locally and the democrat [n.b., no 'ic'] author of the article that stimulated this blog succeeded in distracting us from the economy, unemployment, gas prices and a failed presidency....what to do?? what to do??
do we need stimulant med to keep us on task and not be distracted by intentionally irrelevant stimuli??? no...YOU DO NOT NEED TO ANSWER A BARKING DOG...We, on the other hand, need to turn the tables...When they [left-wing extremists] wave the flag of sexism, homophobia, environmentalism, racism [that's a big one], the uninsured,etc, etc...we do not have to engage but we can re-direct where they don't want it [gas prices, the economy, solyndra, a failed presidency,unemployment]...
Vizsla
8:58 pm on Friday, March 23, 2012
What about the cases of rape or incest? Or when delivering will endanger the womans life?
Dr Geoff Clarke
6:00 am on Saturday, March 24, 2012
You didn't read what I posted earlier. There are medical reasons to perform abortions when a womans life is at risk. Never a pleasent decision but one that is made with far more consideration and discussion with their doctor than finding out one is preganant and needs to get rid of the problem by walking casually into PP and having some uneducated neanderthal at the front desk saying "sign" here when do you want to do it?
Roger Meshberger
8:08 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
Your web rag is obviously biased u are nothing but hacks for the democratic socialists party. Romney is correct !! This is America love it or leave it &take Obama with u!
Roger Meshberger
8:10 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
If u don't agree with the social engineers ur post will b flagged as inappropriate. Buy more guns n ammo piss off the liberals!
Dr Geoff Clarke
8:34 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
BE VERY VERY CAREFUL HERE. There is precious little free speech left at the liberals hands. If you don't agree they look for a reason to close you out. A dear friend of my wife's was taken off here because she is pretty blunt, honest truthful and not PC to the point of vomiting and she was pulled. So when you speak like that you may see your last post pulled and off with your head ..........or voice as the case may be. Goeff
Vizsla
8:59 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
This an op-Ed piece, it is not Patch's opinion. She is the chair of the Sarasota Democratic Party. Do you really think she would espouse Romney's leanings? If you want to provide the other side then do so. Polite and constructive conversation with decorum, not animosity. You catch more flies With honey than vinegar.